Family Planning in NH: Abortion Restrictions

LFDA Editor

The New Hampshire Legislature continues to work through a variety of bills regarding family planning in the state, many of which are controversial throughout the political spectrum.

Parental Notification

In 2011 the legislature overrode Gov. John Lynch's veto of HB 329, a bill which prohibits abortions from being performed on minors without 48 hours' notice to a parent or guardian, with some exceptions. For more information, go to the LFDA's Parental Notification issue page.

Women's Right to Know Act

In 2012 the state legislature considered HB 1659, the so-called "Women's Right to Know Act."  The Act requires doctors to inform women of the medical details of abortion and alternatives prior to scheduling an abortion.  The House passed the bill, but HB 1659 was killed in the Senate.  A 2013 revamp of the Act, HB 483, was rejected by the majority of the House in March 2013.

Supporters of the Women's Right to Know Act argue that abortion is a serious medical decision, and doctors should fully inform women about the possible medical and emotional consequences. 

Opponents of the Women's Right to Know Act argue that the Act is aimed at intimidating women and includes misleading information.  For example, HB 1659 was criticized for requiring doctors to mention a possible link between abortion and breast cancer; that link has been disproved.

Planned Parenthood

In 2011 the Executive Council voted to end a two-year, $1.8 million contract with Planned Parenthood for family planning services, because the organization also offers abortions (about 3 percent of its overall services). The federal government then stepped in to offer funding to the organization.

After that, New Hampshire Right to Life, a pro-life organization, filed a lawsuit charging that the state Board of Pharmacy should have cancelled Planned Parenthood's license to distribute pharmaceuticals following the cancellation of the state contract. Right to Life is focused in particular on the pill RU 486, which is used to induce abortion in the first two months of pregnancy.

Planned Parenthood counters that they have been licensed by the state Board of Pharmacy for more than twenty years, and serve more than half of individuals seeking family planning services in New Hampshire.

In January 2014 the Executive Council voted to reinstate the contract with Planned Parenthood. 

More than a year later, in August 2015, the five-member, Republican-led Executive Council rejected $639,000 in state funding for Planned Parenthood in response to videos showing organization officials discussing the transfer of tissue from aborted fetuses to medical researchers. The videos became the subject of a national controversy.

The rejected funding for Planned Parenthood was part of $1 million in state contracts with four providers of family planning services, which offer testing for sexually transmitted diseases, cancer screenings, and contraception consults. The Council did approve contracts with the Concord Feminist Health Center, the Joan G. Lovering Health Center, and Weeks Medical Center. 

Gov. Hassan said the funding cuts will mean diminished services available for state residents. She commented, “I find it very, very troubling that anyone would vote against these contracts just because the national political climate is a little difficult.”

Rep. Warren Groen is the primary sponsor of HB 677, which prohibits sending any state funds to any health care provider that performs abortions, regardless of whether public funds are utilized for that specific service. The Department of Health and Human Services states this bill would prevent the Department from entering into ANY contract with organizations such as Planned Parenthood. The bill was ultimately voted down in February 2015.

Health Insurance

Under New Hampshire law, health insurance plans provided by employers are required to cover contraceptives.

In 2012 the state legislature considered a provision that would allow religious organizations to exclude contraceptive coverage from insurance plans. The provision was added to an unrelated bill governing religious society rules, SB 356.

Supporters of the provision said that forcing a religious entity to fund contraceptives may violate that organization's right to religious freedom, if the religion does not support contraception.  Opponents said the provision was too broad, allowing organizations that don't necessarily have a religious background to begin refusing contraception coverage.

The exemption was ultimately removed from SB 356.

Criminal Statutes

In 2012 the state legislature passed HB 217, which added the killing of a fetus to the state's homicide statute (the bill excluded legal medical abortions).  Gov. John Lynch vetoed the bill.

Supporters of HB 217 argued that the state has a duty to protect all citizens, including unborn citizens, from crime.  Opponents of HB 217 feared that by granting fetuses "personhood," the legislation was a back-door way of chipping away at reproductive freedoms.

A similar bill, HB 1503, failed in 2014. Now the legislature will consider a 2015 version, HB 560, which was passed by the House in March.

PROS & CONS

"For" Position

"Against" Position

LEGISLATIVE HISTORY

In Committee

Constitutional amendment forbidding any state funding for organizations that provide abortions.

In Committee

Resolution calling for the investigation and defunding of Planned Parenthood.

In Committee

Repeals the protest-free buffer zone around reproductive health care clinics.

In Committee

Establishes a criminal penalty for anyone who "intentionally injures, intimidates or interferes with, or attempts to injure, intimidate or interfere with, another person because such other person was or is obtaining or providing reproductive health services."

In Committee

Prohibits abortions beyond 20 weeks gestation.

In Committee

Requires licensing of outpatient abortion facilities by the Department of Health and Human Services.

In Committee

Prohibits "dismemberment abortion" except in medical emergencies.

In Committee

Prohibits abortion based on genetic abnormality.

In Committee

Prohibits abortion beyond 21 weeks and five days' gestation.

In Committee

Prohibits depriving an infant of nourishment with the intent to cause or alter the death of an infant during an abortion.

In Committee

Prohibits abortions at or after 20 weeks gestation.

In Committee

Imposes several requirements on any physician responsible for providing a patient with Mifeprex, an FDA approved drug meant to induce abortion.

In Committee

Prohibits buying, selling, and experimenting on fetuses or bodily remains resulting from an abortion.

In Committee

Prohibits the use of public funds for the purpose of performing or assisting in an abortion which is not necessary to save the life of the mother, and requires a second opinion from a licensed physician before any abortion is performed when a mother’s life is deemed to be in danger.

Tabled in the Senate

Requires insurers and employers offering insurance to notify policy holders/employees about the details of contraceptive coverage

Passed House and Senate

Includes fetuses eight weeks and older as potential victims under first and second degree murder, manslaughter, negligent homicide, and causing or aiding suicide.

Tabled in the House

Establishes the "Viable Unborn Child Protection Act," which prevents abortions beyond 21 weeks and 5 days gestation

Passed House

Requires the Department of Health and Human Services to keep an annual statistical report on induced termination of pregnancy

Killed in the House

Prohibits sending any state funds to any health care provider that performs abortions, regardless of whether public funds are utilized for that specific service. The Department of Health and Human Services states this bill would prevent the Department from entering into ANY contract with organizations such as Planned Parenthood.

Died in Conference Committee

Includes fetuses as potential victims under murder statutes.  The original Senate version of the bill applied to "viable fetuses," meaning the fetus is old enough to survive outside the womb.  The House revised the bill to apply to all fetuses eight weeks and older.  The House and Senate did not agree on a final version of the bill.

Killed in the House

"All People Create Equal Act," which states that life begins at conception

Killed in the House

Repeals the ability of registered nurses to dispense noncontrolled prescription drugs in clinics that have a contract with the Department of Health and Human Services (such as Planned Parenthood)

Tabled in the Senate

Repeals the law establishing a protest-free buffer zone around reproductive health clinics

Killed in the Senate

Allows pharmacies to dispense oral contraceptives to persons 18 years of age or older without a prescription

Killed in the House

Requiring licenses for outpatient abortion clinics

Interim Study

Requiring the Department of Health and Human Services to keep annual statistics on abortion

Killed in the House

Providing that life begins at conception

Tabled in the Senate

“Fetal Homicide Law,” a bill to include fetuses in murder statutes, but only if the mother is a victim of manslaughter or homicide

Signed by Governor

Authorizing "buffer zones" for protestors around reproductive health clinics

Killed in the House

Requiring doctors to inform women of the medical details of abortion and alternatives prior to scheduling an abortion

Killed in the Senate

"Women's Right to Know Act," mandating that women considering an abortion receive "complete and accurate information on abortion and its alternatives"

Vetoed by Governor

Allowing religious organizations to exclude contraceptive coverage from insurance plans

Vetoed by Governor

Including fetuses as victims in the state homicide statute (excluding legal abortions)

Veto Overridden

Requiring parental notification prior to a minor's abortion

Should NH limit access to abortion?

FOR
REPRESENTATIVES

Add a comment
Add a comment
Add a comment
Add a comment
Add a comment
Add a comment
Add a comment
Add a comment
Add a comment
1 comment(s)
Add a comment
Add a comment
Add a comment
1 comment(s)
Add a comment

AGAINST
REPRESENTATIVES

Add a comment
Add a comment
Add a comment
Add a comment
Add a comment
Add a comment
Add a comment
Add a comment
Add a comment
Add a comment
Add a comment
Add a comment
Add a comment
Add a comment
Add a comment

Comments

Ananta Gopalan
- Hampton

Sun, 03/23/2014 - 9:40pm

New Hampshire is considering through HB 1503 stiffer penalties for the death of fetus as taking life away when the mother is harmed.  That means that the state agrees that a fetus is a human life.  It is about time that the state recognizes existence of a human life growing in a mother's womb.  That is about as natural as the sun rises in the East.

However, in abortion, that same fetus is considered just a conglomeration of cells and tissues and not life.  How can this be called logic based on reasoning?  A different way of looking at this self-imposed conundrum for the sake of political power is that the state grants the privilege to kill that life when its carrier decides against it.

If the pregnant woman was on her way to get an abortion but was shot or harmed in such a way that the fetus is dead, HB1503 will impose penalty upon the perpetrator for causing the death of the fetus.  The human life represented in the fetus in one case can be lawfully killed while in the other case subjected to prosecution.  In either case, the human life loses out!

Can we simply acknowledge that abortion is a violent termination of a human life?  Any amount of spin or demonizing people opposed to it can not alter that fact.  It is funny how in a highly educated society such as ours, we create euphemisms and twisted logic to soothe our conscience.  In the early 1800's, there were prominent people that tried to justify slavery by saying that it was actually good for the black people. But, facts are stubborn things.  Slavery was a criminal act regardless of the twisted logic.  We find ourselves in the same neighborhood in the case of fetus versus human life.

gordona's picture
Gordon Avery
- Salinas

Tue, 08/11/2015 - 11:51am

Planned Parenthood is a windmill of death to the most innocent, most vulnerable, most delicate among us.

.

More than 1.5 million a year -- die by the most brutal methods: salt poisoning, dismemberment, suffocation, strangulation, crushing. It is all done by doctors sworn to heal, sanctioned by judges pledged to uphold our Constitution’s guarantee of the right to life, and condoned by many religious leaders.

.

"America was founded by men and women who shared a vision of the value of each and every individual. Our forebears strove to build a nation in which the dignity of every person was respected and the rights of all were secure. Our laws have sought to foster and protect human life at all its stages. Legal acceptance of abortion imperils this cherished tradition. By permitting the destruction of unborn children throughout the term of pregnancy, our laws have brought about an inestimable loss of human life and potential. Yet the tragedy of abortion extends beyond the loss of the nearly 17 million children who have been robbed of the gift of life. This tragedy is multifaceted -- inflicting emotional harm on women, denying prospective adoptive couples the joy of sharing their loving homes with children, and eroding respect for the most fundamental of rights, the right to life. No cause is more important than restoring respect for this right because the freedoms we hold so dear cannot endure as long as some lives are regarded as unworthy of protection. Nor can our commitment to defend the dignity of all persons survive if we remain indifferent to the destruction of 1.5 million children each year in the United States. ... If America is to remain what God, in His wisdom, intended for it to be -- a refuge, a safe haven for those seeking human rights -- then we must once again extend the most basic human right to the most vulnerable members of the human family." --Ronald Reagan

LEAVE A COMMENT

Log in or register to post comments

Issue Status

In August 2015, the Executive Council rejected $639,000 in state funding for Planned Parenthood in response to videos showing organization officials discussing the transfer of tissue from aborted fetuses to medical researchers. Gov. Hassan expressed her disapproval of the Council's vote. Several representatives have come together on the 2016-2017 legislative session's House Joint Resolution 3 to investigate and defund Planned Parenthood.

For the 2016-2017 legislative session, Rep. Kurt Wuelper has requested HB 1662, a bill to establish the Abortion-Inducing Drugs Safety Act.

Additionally, Rep. Kathleen Souza has requested HB 1663, a bill to prohibit buying, selling, and experimenting on unborn infants or bodily remains resulting from an abortion, as well as HB 1399, which would require the licensure of outpatient abortion clinics by the Department of Health and Human Services; HB 1328, requested by Rep. Joseph Hagan, would establish the Pain-Capable Unborn Child Protection Act, which would prevents abortions beyond 20 weeks gestation; and Rep. Glenn Cordelli is the sponsor of HB 1623, which prohibits abortions based on genetic abnormalities.

Rep. J.R. Hoell has requested HB 1570, a bill to repeal the law that established a "buffer zone" around reproductive health care facilities, limiting the access of protesters; CACR 19, which would prohibit the use of state funds for entities that offer abortions; and HB 1684, which prohibits the use of public funds, employees, and facilities in assisting or performing abortions.

CONTACT ELECTED OFFICIALS » 

Here in NH, your opinion counts. We make it easy to find and reach out to your elected officials about the issues that matter most to you. Click to search and contact your elected officials!

Join the LFDA

Join our constantly growing community. Membership is free and supports our efforts to help NH citizens become informed and engaged. 

JOIN TODAY ▸

©2015 Live Free or Die Alliance | The Live Free or Die Alliance is a 501(c)3 nonprofit organization.